Email Article

Printable Page

"College Hill" Is Vapid, Nauseating

By Russell Nichols
Black College Wire

In the first 10 minutes of BET's new reality TV show, "College Hill," Kevin Mack, a recently "born-again" football star, was caught trying to play the field off the field. It revealed the inherent contradictions destined to plague this series.

"College Hill" looks like a low-budget homemade video, with rejects from MTV's "The Real World" posing as multi-dimensional, goal-oriented characters.

Despite the show's classification, viewers get a false sense of reality when the college characters in the first episode are immediately shown in the club or behind closed doors making up their own "anatomy" exams. Evidently the location, Southern University in Baton Rouge, La., was not critical for what the creators wanted to portray: loose, vapid excuses for intellectuals.

Kinda Andrews, the 18-year-old Baton Rouge native, who everyone calls "No-Drawers," for obvious reasons, gets more spotlight than Delano Mitchell, the aspiring rap artist, and Jabari Roberts, the eccentric computer-science student, combined.

"Everybody has a freak bag in their underwear drawer," Andrews blurts out in one scene. Each time she speaks, it becomes even more clear that "drawers" are not the only thing missing from this girl.

The active camera was intended to create a sense of movement, but the sluggish plot along with the degrading dialogue sequences only made "College Hill" all the more nauseating. The rapid scene changes and random confessional angles make the show seem more like a dim-witted documentary than a reality TV series. Seemingly, Viacom, the parent company of BET, MTV and VH1, is using the so-called black network as its experimental lab rat. But once again, this rat is trapped in tedium.

Although some of the characters and discussions are somewhat identifiable, the show fails to capture the essence of black college life. What about the impressionable children who will watch this show and believe it depicts all that historically black colleges and universities have to offer?

The anticipation was high for the first black college show since "A Different World." However, between the catfight in the street and Andrews' pointless "Kim Possible" rendition, this show is not a different world. It is a disgusting one. And "College Hill" will have to make quite a steep climb to redeem itself.

Russell Nichols, a student at Florida A&M University, writes for The Famuan. He can be reached at [email protected].

Posted Feb. 2, 2004